Don’t Cry Over Spilled Milk Alternatives

By: Thea Boatswain, ’18, University Health Center Nutrition Peer Educator

dont-cry-over-spilled-milk-alternatives-blog-header

Nutrition fads seem to come and go but one that may stick around is drinking milk alternatives.

For some, milk alternatives are a must because of lactose intolerance. Students who are lactose intolerant cannot digest lactose, which is a naturally occurring sugar found in cow’s milk. For those students, drinking a milk alternative, such as soy milk, is great because they are still able to enjoy the pleasures of milk without any of the lactose side effects.organic-milk

For others, the concern of hormones and other additives in the milk have prompted them to forego traditional cows milk. In an article published by the NIH, it states that any pasteurization of the milk destroys the hormones that might be present. It also states that if, by chance, any hormones are ingested by the human body it wont be recognized and will simply pass through the digestive tract, unabsorbed. If you’re still worried about hormones being in the milk you should know the FDA has reported that farmers actually stop giving cows medications in the months before lactation to make sure that all traces of antibiotics or hormones have left the body.

Hormones are just one concern I’ve heard from my Nutrition Coaching clients. Some simply think that cows milk is unhealthy because of fat or caloric content. So I have compiled a list of different types of milk and compared them with traditional milk so that you can make the decision for yourself!

milk-chart

As you can see, skim cows milk has more protein, two grams more than soy milk and seven grams more than rice or almond milk! That’s a huge difference. This whey protein in cow’s milk has been found to support muscle growth after strength training, meaning it can help build strong muscles! Cows milk also has no added sugars. Milk alternatives need additional sweeteners to equal the amount of natural sweetness that is already in cows’ milk.

So if you are avoiding traditional cow’s milk because you feel that it is less healthy than the others, I encourage you to think about it again.  If you choose a milk alternative because you enjoy the taste better, then enjoy those, just make sure it is fortified with calcium anutrition-legendnd Vitamin D.

If you are still concerned about eating dairy products and use one of the dining halls on campus, don’t fret. The dining halls have a handy legend that will tell you what foods contain dairy and other common food allergens/intolerances.

To learn more about ways to meet all your nutritional needs,  reserve your session with a Nutrition Coach today by calling 301-314-5664 or email NutritionCoach@umd.edu.

This entry was posted in Nutrition, Physical Wellness. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Don’t Cry Over Spilled Milk Alternatives

  1. terp says:

    What brand of soy milk only has 6g of protein per cup? Silk Original has 8g, Edensoy Original has 11g, Kirkland Vanilla has 7g, Soy Dream Original has 7g. Another great new option is Ripple’s pea milk which has 8g of protein.

    • Thea B says:

      Hi! Different brands do have differing amounts of nutrients. The information provided is directly from supertracker.usda.gov. The protein information comes straight from this USDA resource and doesn’t specify a brand, the same goes with the other types of milk. Thank you for listing all of the great brands of soy milk too! Im sure people will find it extremely helpful.

  2. Rebecca Heming says:

    Thanks for the helpful chart! I’m going to have to look up goats milk now.

  3. eslattery96 says:

    The chart is a great resource to use! Dairy products shouldn’t be scary, and making sure that they include or are fortified with calcium and vitamin D is incredibly important. Both nutrients are crucial for bone health!

  4. Selena says:

    This is such great information, thank you! As someone who just doesn’t like the taste of cow’s milk, I plan on using this to make sure I’m getting the most nutritious milk alternative I can find.

  5. Ashley Statter says:

    Awesome blog!! Cow’s milk has really been getting a bad rep lately, glad you cleared up this common misconception!

  6. Avital says:

    Thea, what a great chart. Seeing the types of milk alternatives side-by-side with milk was a really good way to get a sense of the nutritional differences.

  7. Thanks Thea for a great job making this very confusing topic much more understandable. It is helpful to see the nutrient breakdown of each type of milk because I think a lot of people don’t realize the differences, especially in protein content.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s